Onions: Immigrants should be valued as job makers

As Americans, we pride ourselves on quite a bit. We’re the greatest, the strongest, the most free, a superpower, a world leader, what have you. And when it comes to technology, at least, the United States has a proud tradition of innovation and entrepreneurship. Look no further than big names like Steve Jobs, Bill Gates, and Mark Zuckerburg, whose products enrich our lives and set high standards for our competition.

But if you look a little closer than All-Americans like Steve, Bill, and Mark, you’ll notice something. Do Pierre Omidyar, Sergey Brin, and Jerry Yang sound familiar? Maybe not. How about eBay, Google, or Yahoo, the companies each of these immigrants helped found?

Those who are fervently “anti-immigrant” are likely blissfully ignorant of the contributions foreign-born researchers, developers, and scientists have made in the United States. After all, it is hard to argue with facts, especially those that reveal that immigrant-founded companies based in the U.S. employ over 400,000 Americans and generate billions in revenue each year. And I don’t hear “anti-immigrant” protestors complaining about the pharmaceuticals, computer systems, and hundreds of other products created through the work of immigrants who are listed as contributors on over 25% of U.S. global patent applications.

People should worry about immigration, but the concern shouldn’t be over who we let into this country; it should be over who we are keeping out.

It may surprise you that in the U.S., over half of the doctorates awarded in mathematics, computer sciences, physics, and economics are earned by students from another country. That number increases to over 60% in engineering. The United States doesn’t have a problem with attracting students to American universities. But after we educate them, our abysmal visa system sends the vast majority of them home to their countries of origin where they create products and services that compete with those in America. Where is the sense in that?

When 64% of Indian students and 68% of Chinese students educated in the U.S. hope to start a business within the next decade, we should be capitalizing on the chance to jumpstart the economy and put Americans to work. We should be finding ways to increase visas for entrepreneurs and innovators, removing barriers to access, and creating environments that welcome the best talent in the world, regardless of origin.

And we better do it soon. While Congress drags its feet through another election year and the public continues to think of immigration as a four-letter word, our competition in the international race for talent is rolling out the welcome mat for the highly-skilled immigrants we are chasing away. While the UK, Canada, Russia, Chile, Brazil, and Singapore reform their systems in order to attract the next Zuckerburg or Omidyar, the U.S. should remember that pride is a dangerous thing. With an immigrant tradition as strong as America’s, we would do well to return to our roots in order to defend our status as the land of opportunity.

Onions is a junior in political science and women, gender, and sexuality studies from Shawnee.

  • Updated May. 1, 2012 at 6:00 am
  • Calvin

    Ms Onion you have no idea of what you are writing about. The fight is not and has never been over immigration. The fight has been over the law requiring immigrants to come into this country legally. For the democrats on the left the law is an inconvenient thing and the right something to be enforced equally for the safety of the country. I’m surprised that you don’t know that but I really do believe that you do know the difference. This is your attempt to curry favor from your friends on the left and to avoid being called a racist. Illegal immigration knows no race but it is the left who is making solely about race. Illegal immigrants (even immigrant is inaccurate as many have no intention of becoming citizens and making this country their home), no illegal aliens come from all over the world and the US is one of the only modern countries that does so little to protect our borders. Try again next week to get the facts straight Ms Onion. We welcome legal immigrants. People who have something to offer and want freedom for themselves. People who are willing to do things the right way.

  • ky102

    Good job Ms Onions. Business owners won’t pay a living wage to Americans so illegals cross the border to do our dirty work. Bush didn’t do a single thing about it in 8 years. But lets blame the left.

  • Thatcher

    We should welcome legal immigration into the United States. However, it does us no good to open our borders to what is essentially 1/3 of the developing world in South and Central America. We should highly encourage all foreign graduates of our universities to stay in the United States and get jobs.

    My wife is a legal immigrant to this country from Eastern Europe. For those of you who’ve never had to deal with any immigration issues/lawyers/embassies/INS/Homeland Security, let me tell you…it is pretty horrible. And on top of that….it is INCREDIBLY expensive. I would estimate that we’ve paid over 4,000 dollars to ensure that my wife remains here on a completely legal basis (never overstayed a visa, never lapsed on immigraiton paperwork, etc). Also, she and I own a business together. Can you imagine the paperwork that we have to submit to ensure that a non-American business owner remains on the up-and-up with the government?

    Having said all of that…who in their right mind would go through all of this red tape and bureaucracy to become a legal citizen when they could just fly here and overstay a tourist visa or run across the non-existent border in the southwest? And who could afford it? Why do we bother to keep our airports on lockdown yet purposely not enforce our physical borders? Why should immigrants from Mexico and Central America be allowed to live by one set of immigration laws while the rest of the world is regulated so strictly simply because they must fly here rather than walk?

    We need to significantly liberalize immigration in this country…but we don’t need to make ourselves the world’s welfare system either.